I was going to revive the old thread, but it looked like it was mostly spam and flames, so here's the new deal. I'm just going to get this started. Very unofficial for now, but what we'll do is this:
Someone will nominate a list of maps, and then each following person will vote y or n for each map in the list. Mark undecided votes with a ?.
This isn't about liking or disliking maps, it's about the quality of team play and strategies the map offers. In other words, if you continuously get owned or confused on a map because you can't sit and spray one entrance, it's probably a good match map. If it's a one-path/box/all-autos map, all of you had better be voting no.
You must be actively participating in a clan to vote. Once a map has, say 5 or more yes votes, or 5 or more no votes, it will be added / discarded.
I'll start with an example:
roundup
warehouse
mirrorr
ub_rooftop
midnight2
crimethink
siegecastle
castle1
jump
pbcup
bombsaway
indune
fort20
Then you would vote, like:
roundup - y
warehouse - ?
mirrorr - y
ub_rooftop - y
midnight2 - y
crimethink - y
siegecastle - y
castle1 - y
jump - y
pbcup - n
bombsaway - n
indune - n
fort20 - n
As maps are approved / disapproved, I'll be updating this post with the approved/unapproved/pending list. We'll see how it goes. Perhaps it will help better set up an official committee. Or maybe we'll just stick with this if it works well.
