outrageous

[GreenAffairz]

yea i guess people wouldnt use it faithfully, maybe only the clan leaders could use it or something :S

[lekky]

but then what would you do with people who claimed to be the clan leader/founder, but wern't actually even in the clan?

[KiLo]

yea i guess people wouldnt use it faithfully, maybe only the clan leaders could use it or something :S

I'm not trying to make more work for Jits but a karma rating for clans may be able to be implemented with the global login. Meaning you have to be listed as a leader of your clan to vote on the karma of other clans.

[Matze]

I don't think taht would work out good at all..

What will a clanleader probably do if he/his clan looses against another clan? So you will have a lot of clans with minus ratings and barely + ratings (Why would a clan leader give an opponent a good rating?)

There may be 2-3 leader who'd vote correctly, but with all the pub/newer clans around it won't do well.

If theres a clan-karma-system it should be regulated under objective factors and persons.

[KiLo]

I don't think taht would work out good at all..

What will a clanleader probably do if he/his clan looses against another clan? So you will have a lot of clans with minus ratings and barely + ratings (Why would a clan leader give an opponent a good rating?)

There may be 2-3 leader who'd vote correctly, but with all the pub/newer clans around it won't do well.

If theres a clan-karma-system it should be regulated under objective factors and persons.

Yeah that is a good point. It probably wouldn't work out.

But if we possibly want it, it should go in The Official Feature Vote of 2007 thread.

[Anarchy]

also, a lot of "newb" clans blame the better clans of hacking. In this sense, i'm using newb as worse. So obviously, they would give negative karma or whatever the hell you want to call it.

[GreenAffairz]

Hmm I guess your right, people can be too stupid for that karma system. Check out my karma, it r0x0rs.

[Spook]

all our karmas "roxors"

[GreenAffairz]

no, its r0x0rs.