I'd been away for a while from playing mainly, but also partly posting in the forums. Back into the matching scene now though.
The 'Replace those deemed inactive" seems like the popular choice, which I don't need to say makes sense! Also means people are generally happy with the members that are active. I think its a good way to go, add to those that are active some new blood. Its always a good idea to mix things up, get some new ideas and thought processes going on to keep it all fresh.
I would say the last nomination process was fairly well done, similar thing this time (for a total replacement, or addition of some members)?