Author Topic: Official Maplist: Vote (Read 17900 times)

jitspoe · « **on:** May 13, 2013, 04:48:42 PM »

Before voting, please see the Official Maplist: Discussion thread to get a better idea of what this is about.

Place your vote by replying with a list of all maps you think should be official. You get 1 vote in this thread, but you can vote for as many maps as you want. Do not post more than one reply in this thread. If you wish to change your votes, edit your original post. If you wish to debate about the selection of certain maps, do so here. If somebody has posted more than once or has posted something other than a maplist vote, use the "Report to moderator" link.

Focus on maps that have good gameplay. Most maps will likely have a pass done on them to improve the visuals (or perhaps be completely reconstructed). Beta maps are OK to vote for. They will simply need to be completed before inclusion on the final list.

After a while (maybe 1 month), we will tally up the votes, pick the top map, and spend the next month or so getting the map fixed and polished. Then tally the votes again, pick the next top map, and so on.

Now, cast your votes:

MyeRs · « **Reply #1 on:** May 13, 2013, 05:52:08 PM »

Carpathian, Pbcup_Pforest, Pbcup_Sassault, Propaint1, Castle1, Pbcup_Renoir(With some rework)

Rick · « **Reply #2 on:** May 13, 2013, 06:51:53 PM »

Twiling_b3; Very cool map. Looks awesome and has awesome gameplay.
Rome; Not the best looking map but takes strategy to play.
pbcup_pforest; Either the best, or the second best DT map.
Shock; Every newbie loves this map, redesign it and chuck it back into the game.
Shazamr; My personal favourite of the series. (Not 33).
Zpar11_beta; Looks and plays amazing. Maybe a bit too hard for newbies.
Airtime; Popular map, not hard for newbies and is a lot of fun. Redesign.
Castle1; Very strategic.
Destiny; Pretty cool map, a little jumping is beneficial, not needed though.
hmpf; Love this map. Great idea, maybe just fix a few flaws.
Macabre; Fix the leaks. Fun map.
nml; Good map.
Mystique; Maybe? I'm not sure.
pbcup_pbsanc; FUN MAP.
Sassault4; A nice cuso map.
prolandr; obviously.
pp1/pp2; I think I like pp2 more, but pp1 is still good.
Slippery; Pretty cool map. Thanks Termi.
tlc; Fun, strategic map.
ub_columbia; Hard map for newbs, fun map for Pro's.

SuperMAn · « **Reply #3 on:** May 15, 2013, 10:55:22 AM »

I haven't really played in a while so I don't know most of the newer maps. But here are the maps I think should at least be considered.

Airtime2 or 3: I think the first airtime is just too plain/boring, very defence/team oriented map though.
Twiling_b3: I've always liked this map, I think it looks great and like Rick said it plays pretty well too.
Prolandr: Great map, high skill cap
Pbcup_sassault: Probably one of the best maps for matching ever.
Pbcup_pbsanctuary: Very defensive map, looks great, plays well.
Carpathian: Awesome DT map.
Pbcup_Pforest: Another awesome DT map.

Maybe shazam22 if it was bigger.

That is all I can think of at the moment. I don't remember many maps anymore, I will come back and add to this list later.

ViciouZ · « **Reply #4 on:** May 15, 2013, 12:09:17 PM »

Airtime: Classic, well known, teaches newbies to use ramps, still used in matches.
Shazam*: Another classic design, some kind of slight enlargement of shaz22 without losing the nice 'cosy' lighting or adding the random extra s33 camping rooms would be nice.
Perf/sassault*: One of these would be good to modernise, probably based on pbcup_sassault.
Castle1 because castle1. Might be able to light it a little nicer along the way.

Those would be my top nominations.

Foxhound · « **Reply #5 on:** May 15, 2013, 12:37:17 PM »

Dream_b1 - by rassy
Propaint 1
Propaint 2
Carp
Mystique
Twiling_b3
Macabre
Ub_Columbia
NML
Destiny
Zpar
Airtime
PBcup_pforest
Tatras

@ baseball dude.. no one put razzle or daylight. Just put what you want, it's all getting tallied. Your neg votes don't mean a darn thing.

HaRmonY · « **Reply #6 on:** May 15, 2013, 12:39:29 PM »

green_park_b4
theraden_b2
insight_b3
sroads_b3
zephyrus_b6
sanctum_b4
cream
nml
northmines
cya
destiny
sanctum_inner

BASEBALLDUDE · « **Reply #7 on:** May 16, 2013, 07:23:17 PM »

There are many great maps out there, but here I will list a few that are often overlooked despite their greatness.

-nhb: great map, lots of paths and strategic gameplay. Also looks very nice.
-freedom: great gameplay but needs more balancing
-pbcup_2fort5: gameplay and looks
-ub_rooftop: great gameplay and aesthetics that fit the theme nicely
-italy: The only great map that has uneven bases. There is no clear team with an advantage.

And here are some maps that I think are overrated and should not become official:

-razzle: BORING
-daylight: too much ice; although it's fun, gameplay is not good.

Note: Do not count this as my votes; I have a separate post in this thread for my votes.

MrPeach · « **Reply #8 on:** May 17, 2013, 11:31:33 AM »

-airtime
-carpathian
-castle1
-crimethink
-duck_fix
-grave
-oth
-pbcup
-pbcup_pforest
-propaint1
-propaint2
-remenission
-shazam22
-shock
-sphouse
-ub_cliff

@RobinandL!nk It's good map for newbies, they like maps like remenission, shock, shazam33 or grave. That's why i think it should be on the list.

RoBiNandL!nk · « **Reply #9 on:** May 17, 2013, 11:49:29 AM »

Quote from: MrPeach on May 17, 2013, 11:31:33 AM

-airtime
-carpathian
-castle1
-crimethink
-duck_fix
-grave
-oth
-pbcup
-pbcup_pforest
-propaint1
-propaint2
-remenission
-shazam22
-shock
-sphouse
-ub_cliff

remenission? Officially the worst dp map created.
duck_fix? Needs more fixing to be on the map list...

Only maps i think that could make the cut:

carpathain -- Best Looking
pbcup_sassault
propaint1
propaint2
pbcup_pforest
pbcup_pbsanctuary
castle1 -- Best Gameplay
Prolandr
Rome
pbcup_renoir
grave
wobluda

my list has both offensive minded and defensive minded maps

Defensive --
propaint2
grave
propaint1
pbcup_pbsanctuary
pbcup_sassault
castle1

Offensive
pbcup_pforest
Prolandr
Rome
pbcup_renoir
wobluda

But I also think that more match maps and public maps need to have more different types of game modes.. more siege maps, more deathmatch maps.. etc. If we had a good enough quantity and quality of deathmatch maps then speed servers will be irrelevant

@MrPeach Reminission has the tallest walls in any map I've ever seen. It's the ugliest map on paintball. I'm sure we can find more newbie friendly maps then reminissions..

Rocky · « **Reply #10 on:** May 20, 2013, 12:41:05 PM »

-airtime
-pbcup
-pbcup_renoir
-pbcup_pforest
-nml
-castle1
-crimethink
-propaint1
-shazam22
-moonlit2r1
-snowbong

Clipz · « **Reply #11 on:** May 21, 2013, 07:42:40 AM »

Carpathian, Midnight. Pbcup, Pbcup_pforest, pbcup_renoir, Shazam22 or Shazamr, Sandtrap, Wobluda OR airtime. (I hate both, but newbs have hardons for them) sroads_b3 and Propaint1.
(list not done)

Now time to get a little biased: Mystique, TLC, NML and Rallyr_b1.

I've seen other people vote on them, obviously anyone would nominate some of their own maps and want them on the "official" list..

[cP]Pb2x · « **Reply #12 on:** May 24, 2013, 09:48:32 PM »

I will second pretty much what Clipz voted for, I think he has a good feel of what belongs. I would vote for Green Park and Nonturno also.

omni · « **Reply #13 on:** May 25, 2013, 02:52:04 AM »

-Carpathian - Very Good map
-Destiny - Good looking map, very underplayed
-Zephrus - If it's gets finished it would make for a great map
-CCC - If the lag at the exits of the base is fixed this would be great for newbies

These are the only maps I would actually be happy seeing; Also maps that newbies will actually see as high quality. But CCC lag will have to be fixed.

rockitude · « **Reply #14 on:** May 25, 2013, 08:22:51 AM »

- airtime
- beta/green_park_b4
- carpathian
- castle1
- crossroad99
- grave
- jump
- london
- pbcup_pforest
- pbcup_sassault
- propaint1
- rome
- ub_abbey

Would be in list with remake (just the mistakes, no new stuff):

- shazam22
- pbcup_renoir (remove water to increase the fps)

CheMiCal · « **Reply #15 on:** May 25, 2013, 03:26:39 PM »

- airtime
- beta/green_park_b4
- carpathian
- castle1
- zpar
- pbcup_renoir_fix
- wobluda( because its a map people somehow like)
- shazam22
- pbcup_pforest
- pbcup_sassault
- propaint1 or propaint2
- rome or sphouse
- prolandr
- OTH
- and of course sroads_b3

- destiny could be an option too.

Nye · « **Reply #16 on:** May 25, 2013, 05:10:08 PM »

- cream
- nml
- 1day
- litt
- oth
- carpathian
- castle1
- ub_abbey
- jinious_b2
- sroads_b3
- beta/green_park_b4
- pbcup_pforest
- pbcup_sassault
- theraden_b2
- krakatit_b3

Morphin · « **Reply #17 on:** June 06, 2013, 09:26:19 AM »

airtime
zephyrus
pbcup_pforest
pbcup_sassault
pbcup_renoir
rome
prolandr
shazam22
castle1
carpathian
macabre
pp1
wobluda_fix
pp_sw
greenhill
duck_fix
xbmap1
tunels
temple22

Narga · « **Reply #18 on:** June 06, 2013, 01:03:23 PM »

urbann_b4
wobluda
carpathian
green_park_b4
airtime3
london
proppaint1 (Was there also a propaint2 & 3?)
prolandr

Chalk · « **Reply #19 on:** June 17, 2013, 04:21:09 PM »

propaint1
airtime
wobluda
carpathian
zpar
pbcup_pforest
nml
oth
shazam33