Robin my opinion is almost the same as yours except I also like American Idiot. Stuff like Holiday still sounds like the old Green Day, and September and Boulevard sound good even though they are kinda pop-ish. But good riddance is probably the most overplayed song in history; I've never seen a graduation slideshow that doesn't use that song.
Good Riddance isn't even that good tbh... Songs like Burnout, Sassafras roots, Christe Road, Long View, Basket Case, Chump, When I Come Around, Brain Stew, Jaded. THATS Good Green Day.
21st Century Breakdown is my favorite album, my opinion is that of both of yours except later once again --> I don't like Uno Dos or Tre so much. 21 Guns is the most over-rated/ played IMO.
Check out Hopes and Fears by Keane I forgot I liked them so much and I got a pleasant surprise when i heard the album again. Thats there best if you ask me.
21 guns is HORRIBLE. He says the same thing over and over and over and over and over again.