Not even going to waste time going through and reading all the posts in this - "this games dead" - "adds trash talk of unskilled players - "continues replying to everyone" ---> Hey everyone, it's Toxiic on a new account. You can tell by his attempt to be grammatically correct, but failing. Also, his mention of league of legends, poor attempt of trash talk, and the way he writes.
HEY TOXIIC.
Now, in terms of "when was the last time these players played with nonames" -- Well, let's just say hypothetically they don't. Hypothetically they are unskilled. In a game over 3v3, where Shockwave is "above average" as you stated, and Myers/Chemical are bad. How does that 3v3 team win consistently against most teams? And the teams that have beaten them, they have beaten too. That would mean, either Shockwave is the best player in this game and can carry 2 awful teammates in order to beat everyone else, or his teammates aren't bad. Now, further to argue your skilled points - you literally named some of the most relevant names in the matching scene to call out as poor. Skill isn't a numerical thing in DP, its subjective, but, "good" is based on competing with others. In terms of competing with other players, every player you mentioned is in the top 10% of the game, therefore are skilled. Myers/Chem/Jeo etc..
Also, your comment about league of legends and toxicity is wrong. League is 100x more toxic than DP2, more excrement talk. Sure, it's bannable. But only about 1% of that game gets perma banned, and most of the time its not for toxicity. Larger games with larger communities actually have more toxicity. The things I say in DP2 would NOT BE BANNABLE in any other game. And, to be honest, people probably wouldn't get butthurt. The only things in League that can get you banned is if you make death threats or very racist remarks - arrogance isnt bannable.
In terms of why the games dying, they weren't "smart points" or "researched points" - they were common sense that have all been stated numerous times by numerous different people. Everyone has a theory for why the games dying. People say "OH THE excrement TALK" have clearly not played other competitive games. You said some good points as to why the games dying, but every point has been said before. Congratulations, you're not smart, you're a noname whos hiding behind an alias because you know that if you wrote on your main account (if its not banned) you'd get no credibility - If you just left your first post as is, instead of showing your true colours, maybe your topic would have been taken seriously.
PS: Your analogy about the committee was hilarious at best. You don't understand the purpose of the committee, and given you mentioned their job being voting on bans, it furthers the awareness that you're a banned player, hence ToXiiC.
@DooCi - If it was constructive and showing his caring about the game, it wouldn't be a permanently banned player writing it. Clearly his caring for the game went wrong somewhere. A guy who intentionally hacked teams? Yeah, I think he must really care. He also hacked teams of the people he claimed were unskilled, just so he can pretend he was a part of their teams.... odd? I always avoided having teams of bad players on my formers.