Like the pbcup '06 rules? Remind me of what written rules said and what was done. Remind me what was done then.
Seeing as this is an argument/discussion/whatever between you and Eiii, how about you leave PBCup out of this? He wasn't a "ref", admin, organizer or participant of either seasons that were run. I will admit that there were some bad decisions made by our refs, the administration team and most of all myself; both in terms of how the league was operated and how the rules were enforced. I've already taken enough scrutiny, criticism, flaming, death threats (lol), had the database and website taken hostage, etc.
It's been eighteen months since then, and I've probably helped hundreds of people between IRC and the Help & Support forum, handed out practically every one of my scrim/match demos from the last year to players who are looking to improve their game, helped new leaders develop their clans, and even ran a couple very successful tournaments.
You on the other hand have dedicated countless hours towards this
"iron fist"-approached
(mis)administration of the GT servers and have always made sure to justify your actions with skewed logic.