I am so late to this discussion. But since things seem to have gotten worse. What harm could adding my 2 cents do?
Why I left?
New commitments, new interests(related and unrelated to games)
Crap internet connection
Sort of forgot about it ^^;
What would make me come back?
Well I am back sort of, but...
The previous variety in maps.
As well as some of the maps that were around 5 to 6 years ago.(classic maps?)
Hmm, not really sure what else. Since I've currently started playing again
I agree with some of the suggestions here. For me, long spawn times are devastating to a game. Especially if I'm playing on a map I hate. :/ 30 sec should be the max. With 10-15 sec the minimum. As for matches, I'm fine with higher respawn times. Or 1 life per round. Just seems weird any other way. I would love spawn protection. I played a simple map earlier.(that I like a lot) And someone from the other team took it upon their selves to sit at our base and shoot continuously. I don't think speed servers killed DP. And I don't choose a server that way when I want to play.
And I have to agree, I don't really know SuperMAn, but I enjoyed playing on his server. It seemed to have a better variety compared to other servers when I played in my earlier years. And he seemed open to suggestions. So that's always nice.
Personally I don't agree with 10 map max per server. Most of the people in charge seem to like the same maps. Which means there isn't really a variety in the maps. I'm tired of seeing the same couple of maps. Personally I would like to see some of these beta maps finished. There's only like 3 or 4 servers that have people on it. So when it's a map I've gotten sick of playing. I go to empty servers to check out the beta maps.
I don't think learning a map is the problem. If anything maybe a offline tutorial version could made for more popular maps. A tutorial well never be the "be all, end all". I was in a map the other day.(probably a jump map) And someone was asking how to do something. When they were asked if they had done the tutorial they said no.
Also, I love Carpathian. I wasn't very good at it, and probably never will be. But I enjoyed playing it.
I think we need more innovative maps. Some that aren't some random cave. I actually like having the possibility to play on a variety of maps. So I don't bored and used to the same gameplay.
By the way, I enjoy playing PB2 as well as other people multiplayer games like COD. You can't really compare the two. For one thing COD has the power to have random objects you can and can't interact with. As well as the budget to keep implementing that feature.
Almost forgot. More or new sounds would be nice. I always found that funny when I first started playing. And I didn't really mind dying when I heard them.
I think that's it. Maybe I missed something. But I hope we can manage to bring more people to paintball. My posts are always so long. -_-